Vehicle confiscation appeal following his brother's cannabis conviction
Current status of the Vehicle confiscation appeal following his brother's cannabis conviction
This is not a criminal case against Piyal Manamperi. The Supreme Court judgment (SC Appeal No. 249/2017) names the appellant as 'W.M. Piyal Senadheera'; Nadu treats the appellant as Piyal Manamperi on an inferred basis (the facts match the cannabis conviction of his brother Sampath Manamperi), but the surname in the judgment differs and the identification has not been confirmed.
What follows describes the judgment on that inferred basis. His elder brother, Sampath Preethi Viraj, borrowed Piyal's registered vehicle (a black Toyota double cab, No. SP PE 1214) on 28 March 2013 to move a paddy harvesting machine; Sampath was arrested that same day by the Special Task Force after the vehicle was found to have been used to transport cannabis, and was later convicted of trafficking and possessing 106 kg 105 g of Cannabis Sativa (see sampath-manamperi-01).
Read the full account (3 more paragraphs)Show less
After Sampath's conviction, the High Court of Monaragala held an inquiry into the vehicle and, on 6 December 2016, refused to release it to Piyal and ordered it confiscated under section 79 of the Poisons, Opium and Dangerous Drugs Ordinance. Piyal challenged that order - first by a revision application to the Court of Appeal (dismissed 14 September 2017), then by appeal to the Supreme Court (SC Appeal No. 249/2017).
The Supreme Court dismissed Piyal's appeal on 20 February 2024, affirming the confiscation. The Court held that although Piyal was a third-party owner who had not been a party to the cannabis offence itself, he had failed to prove - on the civil, balance-of-probabilities standard that applies to a confiscation inquiry, not a criminal standard - that he lacked knowledge of the vehicle's intended use or had taken precautions to prevent it, given that he knew Sampath (a police officer who had been interdicted from service over other alleged offences) had a history of alleged misconduct.
Piyal was never charged, prosecuted, or convicted of any drug offence himself.
What’s happened
Identity caveat: the judgment names the appellant 'W.M. Piyal Senadheera'; that this is Piyal Manamperi is inferred, not confirmed. The Supreme Court's finding on the knowledge/precautions question determined only whether the vehicle could be returned to Piyal - it is not a criminal finding and carries no criminal liability, charge, or sentence for Piyal.
Recorded separately from piyal-manamperi-01 (the unrelated 2025 Middeniya investigation) because the two arise from entirely unrelated events over a decade apart.
- Court
- Supreme Court of Sri Lanka (SC Appeal No. 249/2017); Court of Appeal (CA (PHC) APN 04/2017); High Court of Monaragala (HC 79/2014)
- Next hearing / due
- No upcoming hearing announced
Sources (1)
- Nature
- Civil-type forfeiture inquiry about a vehicle; the vehicle owner was not charged with any offence
- Law
- Section 79, Poisons, Opium and Dangerous Drugs Ordinance (as amended by Act No. 13 of 1984)
- Vehicle
- Black Toyota double cab, registration SP PE 1214, owned by the appellant
- Underlying offence
- The owner's brother convicted on his guilty plea of trafficking/possessing 106 kg 105 g of cannabis
- Court
- Supreme Court, SC Appeal No. 249/2017 (from CA (PHC) APN 04/2017; HC Monaragala 79/2014)
- Outcome
- Appeal dismissed 20 February 2024; confiscation affirmed
- Identity note
- The judgment names the appellant as W.M. Piyal Senadheera; whether he is the politician Piyal Manamperi is not confirmed in the judgment
What happened
On 28 March 2013 the vehicle's owner, a businessman, allowed his elder brother, W.M. Sampath Preethi Viraj, to borrow a black Toyota double cab (registration SP PE 1214) to bring a paddy harvesting machine. The brother was a former police officer who had been interdicted from the service.
At about 5.30 p.m. the same day the owner learned that his brother had been arrested at Thanamalwila. He went to the police station with the brother's wife and found that the Special Task Force had arrested him on an allegation of transporting cannabis. The vehicle was seized as a court production.
The Supreme Court judgment names the appellant as W.M. Piyal Senadheera of Thalawa South, Kariyamadiththa, and describes him as the owner and the arrested man's brother. Whether the appellant is the same person as the SLPP former local councillor Piyal Manamperi, under whose name this matter is tracked, has not been confirmed.
The charges
The vehicle owner was never charged. The charges were against his brother, who was indicted in the High Court of Monaragala for trafficking and possessing 106 kg 105 g of cannabis (Cannabis Sativa). The brother pleaded guilty and was convicted; the Supreme Court judgment says a prison sentence was imposed and suspended for 10 years, together with a fine.
The legal question was what should happen to a vehicle used to carry the drugs when its registered owner is a different person. Section 79 of the Ordinance says a vehicle used to convey the drugs is forfeited to the State on conviction, and says nothing about third-party owners.
How it reached court
After the conviction the Magistrate had earlier released the vehicle to the owner on a bond, but the High Court judge then held an inquiry in which both the owner and his brother gave evidence. On 6 December 2016 the High Court refused to release the vehicle and ordered it confiscated.
The owner sought revision in the Court of Appeal, which dismissed the application on 14 September 2017. He then appealed to the Supreme Court. President's Counsel Anil Silva argued that the section does not require an owner to prove he took precautions, and that confiscating an innocent third party's vehicle would be arbitrary. State Counsel argued the courts were entitled to look at the owner's knowledge and precautions. A three-judge bench heard the appeal on 12 December 2023.
Where it stands
On 20 February 2024 the Supreme Court (Justice Priyantha Fernando, with Justices Amarasekara and Gooneratne agreeing) dismissed the appeal. It read into section 79 the protection found in other laws, under which a third-party owner can keep the vehicle by showing that he took precautions or that it was used without his knowledge, but held that the owner had not shown this on a balance of probabilities.
The court reasoned that he knew his brother had been interdicted from the police over alleged malpractice and took no precautions. This was a decision about the vehicle only; it is not a finding that the owner committed any offence, and there is nothing further pending in this matter.
The matter was decided on the inquiry evidence summarised in the Supreme Court's judgment, which records the facts rather than full testimony. The items below are those the judgment mentions; the court applied a civil standard (balance of probabilities) to the owner.
Evidence is listed as it has been presented in proceedings or publicly reported, with the defence’s position where it has been made public. Evidence being presented is not a finding of guilt — only a court can make one.
- #1Official findingAccepted by court
Sampath Preethi Viraj's guilty plea and conviction for the cannabis offence
Prosecution says
The State relied on the High Court conviction of the brother for trafficking and possessing 106 kg 105 g of cannabis, the precondition for forfeiture under section 79.
Defence says
No public response on this point.
Court's view
The Supreme Court recorded that he pleaded guilty, was convicted and received a 10-year suspended sentence with a fine, and treated the vehicle as used to convey the drugs.
Sources (1)
- #2Statement / admissionAccepted by court
The owner's admission that he lent the vehicle
Prosecution says
The State's position was that the owner permitted his brother to use the vehicle.
Defence says
The owner's position, as recorded, was that his brother asked to borrow the vehicle only to bring a paddy harvesting machine and that he learned of the arrest that evening.
Court's view
The judgment records that he admittedly allowed his brother to borrow the vehicle.
Sources (1)
- #3WitnessPresented in court
Evidence of the owner and his brother at the High Court inquiry
Prosecution says
The State argued that the owner's own evidence showed he knew his brother had a criminal record and should therefore have taken precautions.
Defence says
The owner's case was that he had no role in the offence and no knowledge of the intended use. The reported judgment does not detail his answers.
Court's view
The High Court refused to release the vehicle on 6 December 2016; the Supreme Court said the owner had been given an opportunity to show cause, so he had not been denied a hearing.
Seen in the timeline: 20 February 2024 (Appeal Filed)
Sources (1)
- #4CircumstantialAccepted by court
The brother's status as an interdicted former police officer
Prosecution says
The State said the owner knew the borrower had a history of alleged misconduct, so he should have been vigilant.
Defence says
No public response on this point.
Court's view
The Supreme Court said the owner was well aware his brother had been interdicted over alleged offences and malpractice, and found he took no precautions.
Sources (1)
- #5CircumstantialPresented in court
Quantity of cannabis (106 kg 105 g)
Prosecution says
State Counsel submitted that so large a quantity must have been pre-planned, so the owner ought to have known.
Defence says
No public response on this point.
Court's view
The judgment records this submission but does not rely on the quantity in its reasoning.
Sources (1)
Vehicle confiscation appeal following his brother's cannabis conviction timeline
- 20 February 2024
Appeal Filed
(Identity inferred: the judgment names the appellant 'W.M. Piyal Senadheera'.) The Supreme Court decided Piyal's appeal (SC Appeal No. 249/2017, argued 12 Dec 2023) against the Court of Appeal's 2017 dismissal of his revision application. The Court dismissed his appeal and affirmed the High Court's order confiscating his vehicle, finding he had not shown, on a balance of probabilities, that he lacked knowledge of its use in his brother's cannabis offence.
Read more (1 more paragraph)Show less
This is a civil forfeiture ruling, not a criminal conviction of Piyal.
Court: Supreme Court of Sri Lanka
Sources (1)

